A supplier charge and a client expense are separate decisions
Track supplier costs, invoice credits and client reimbursement in a Texas PI matter, with a provider-check worksheet and links to Texas ethics guidance.
A Texas personal injury firm may be able to recover an eligible provider-verification expense from a client, but a vendor invoice alone does not establish that right. Review the actual work, applicable rules and client agreement. Keep three amounts separate: what the supplier charged, what the firm approved for client reimbursement, and what the client actually reimbursed. For example, a completed medical balance call can produce both a provider response and a service charge. The response supports the case workflow; the charge belongs in the firm's supplier records. Whether it also belongs in the client's expense statement requires counsel's review. Calling it a case disbursement does not make it automatically recoverable or make the service free.
What do the Texas sources say?
Texas Ethics Opinion 705 discusses per-use generative AI expenses. It says recovery may be possible when allowed by law and accepted by the client, and generally limits recovery to the expense actually incurred and paid to the provider. The opinion does not approve VerifyMD or every automated service. Firm counsel still needs to assess the particular work and arrangement.
Texas Ethics Opinion 594 addresses third-party expenses in a personal injury matter. Without contrary disclosure and agreement, the amount recouped must reflect what the lawyer actually paid, including a supplier discount. The opinion treats an undisclosed difference as additional compensation, not simply an expense. Preserve credits and adjustments with the original charge so the cost record does not overstate the amount paid.
Texas Rule 1.04(d) requires a written contingent-fee agreement that addresses expense deductions and whether they occur before or after the fee calculation. It also requires a written conclusion statement describing the outcome and, when there is a recovery, the client's remittance and its calculation. The current court-published rules are effective March 7, 2025. Use the firm's approved agreement and cost policy rather than a vendor's marketing description to decide how an expense is treated.
Build one cost record for each requested check
Use the following fields in your existing case-cost process. They are an operational worksheet, not an engagement clause or a determination that a charge is permissible. The responsible attorney should approve the classification and handling. Restrict client information to approved systems; a public checklist or demo does not need live case details.
Swipe across the table to see every column. Keyboard users can focus the table and use the arrow keys.
| Field | What to preserve | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Matter and task | Internal matter reference, provider, requested verification type and account or date scope | Identifies the work purchased without treating every activity on the file as the same check |
| Completion evidence | Approved result, source reference, completion date and reviewer | Separates a completed service from an attempt or unresolved request |
| Supplier charge | Invoice reference, agreed rate, original amount and any credit | Keeps the quoted price and subsequent adjustments visible |
| Actual supplier payment | Payment date and amount, linked to the invoice and credit record | Distinguishes an invoice from an amount paid |
| Client-expense decision | Attorney decision, applicable cost-policy reference and agreement provision | Records the basis for treating or declining the charge as a client expense |
| Expense-statement treatment | Approved amount and the applicable deduction treatment under the agreement | Supports reconciliation with the final statement without inventing a standard fee formula |
| Actual reimbursement | Amount received, date and supporting accounting reference | Separates a possible reimbursement from a completed collection |
| Open exception | Unresolved question, responsible person and next review date | Keeps missing evidence or a disputed classification visible |
A useful cost record points to the supporting work without duplicating the whole case file. Link the approved result, supplier invoice and payment or credit record. Keep a separate reason when client reimbursement is declined, deferred or still unresolved. A blank reimbursement field should remain unknown rather than silently becoming a collectible expense.
A fictional matter: three completed checks and one credit
Fictional example: a firm authorizes three standard provider checks for one matter. All three produce supported results that the team approves, creating a $30 supplier charge at $10 each. A fourth request remains unconfirmed and has no verification fee. The supplier then issues a $5 credit, and the firm pays $25. The invoice, credit and payment record stay together.
The following alternatives show why supplier cost and client reimbursement need separate columns. The middle and final rows assume counsel has determined that the $25 charge is permitted and covered by the client's agreement. They are arithmetic examples, not predicted collections or a model settlement statement. Staff review time and other firm costs are outside these figures. Applicable tax and separately scoped work are excluded from this example.
Swipe across the table to see every column. Keyboard users can focus the table and use the arrow keys.
| State | Supplier amount paid | Client reimbursement received | Supplier cost still borne by firm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Client-expense eligibility not yet decided | $25 | $0 | $25; no client recovery assumed |
| Eligible and approved, but not collected | $25 | $0 | $25 until reimbursement occurs |
| Eligible $25 reimbursement actually collected | $25 | $25 | $0 of this supplier cost; review effort and other costs remain |
Does payment depend on the case settling?
No. VerifyMD's published standard rate is $10 USD per completed provider verification. One check covers one requested verification type for one provider and case within the agreed account, date or appointment scope; the result requires supporting evidence and the firm's approval. No completed result means no verification fee. Completing the requested service is different from winning or settling the legal case. The firm's supplier obligation does not wait for client reimbursement; review the agreed service terms and any separately agreed volume rate.
Can every software or staff cost become a case expense?
No. Keep general platform costs, setup and staff time separate for review. Opinion 594 distinguishes overhead and in-house services from outside expenses and discusses different limits for them. A matter tag does not settle that classification. Do not create a second charge for work already included elsewhere, or describe time saved by automation as hours actually worked. The national case-expense guide explains the broader recordkeeping distinction.
What should the team review before closing the cost entry?
Before closing the entry, reconcile the supplier side and the client side independently. If the case produces no recovery, do not assume either that the client must pay or that the supplier charge disappears. Counsel should review the client's agreement and applicable law, then record the decision and any remaining balance. This checklist does not authorize withdrawing or distributing client funds.
- Match the approved result to the correct matter, request and supplier charge.
- Apply recorded credits and confirm the amount actually paid.
- Confirm counsel has approved the client-expense treatment under the agreement and applicable rules.
- Check that the same expense has not already been recovered through another entry.
- Record what was actually collected, what remains unresolved and who owns the next decision.
An approved client expense is not cash received. Record actual reimbursement only when it occurs. Reimbursement may offset an eligible supplier cost, while the firm still spends time reviewing results and handling exceptions. That distinction makes a pilot easier to evaluate: compare supported results, review effort, supplier cost and actual reimbursement without treating an invoice as revenue.
Start with a scoped provider task
If medical balance follow-up is taking attention from other case work, start with one defined provider question. Review VerifyMD's pricing and case-cost scope, then try the sample workflow or book a workflow demo to discuss permissions, evidence and setup. This article provides operational information for a Texas firm's review, not a legal opinion approving a particular client charge. Sources and product terms were checked on October 23, 2026.
Explore provider follow-up and source review for your firm. Live calls require agreed setup and activation.
Book a demo